The "Pre-Mandamus" Checklist: Steps to Take Before Suing IRCC
Feeling stuck waiting for an IRCC decision? Before you consider suing for unreasonable delays, it’s vital to be prepared. Our guide walks you through a 'Pre-Mandamus Checklist,' drawing lessons from real Federal Court cases to help you assess your situation.
Steps to Take Before Suing IRCC for Delays
Before launching a mandamus application to sue IRCC for unreasonable processing delays, it is crucial to complete a thorough pre-mandamus checklist. This legal action, which asks the Federal Court to compel a decision, is an extraordinary remedy and requires a strong, well-prepared case. The first step is to ensure you have not contributed to the delay by failing to submit a complete application or respond to requests, a principle highlighted in cases like Mahboobehsadat Emadi v. The Minister of Citizenship and Immigration, 2025 FC 1316.
Next, the delay must be proven to be 'prima facie' unreasonable, often by demonstrating it significantly exceeds published processing times. The Federal Court has consistently found that IRCC cannot rely on vague justifications. As seen in Saqib Javed v. The Minister of Citizenship and Immigration, 2025 FC 987, blanket statements about security checks are deemed inadequate. However, legitimate and complex security concerns, as in Cheloei v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2025 FC 820, can justify longer waits. Finally, applicants should understand the nature of a Judicial Review; if a decision is made before the hearing, the case may become moot, as occurred in Mao v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2025 FC 932.
- Confirm Compliance: Ensure your application is complete and you've met all IRCC requirements.
- Document the Delay: Compare your wait time to official standards to establish it is unreasonable.
- Assess Justifications: Prepare to challenge generic excuses from IRCC for the delay.
Full article on dadkhah.ca